High court considers whether to let jobless false fraud case proceed


A lawyer representing individuals who were falsely accused of unemployment fraud years ago argued Wednesday before the Michigan Supreme Court that Michigan’s violation of his clients’ due process rights merits monetary damages beyond the reimbursement of unemployment benefits that were taken from them. 

But a lawyer for the state said the jobless benefits case doesn’t meet the standard of a due process rights violation. 

Attorney Mark Granzotto argued to the high court that it should let his clients proceed with what could amount to a multimillion dollar lawsuit against the state. The state usually is exempt from monetary damages because of Michigan’s governmental immunity law, but suits filed under constitutional claims are expected to bypass state law. 

The false fraud unemployment scandal dates back to a state-run computer program that falsely accused thousands of people between 2013 and 2015 of unemployment fraud, which was then, in many cases, collected on by the state. For some individuals who had to return the jobless aid they received, the burden led to bankruptcies and foreclosures.

The Michigan Supreme Court heard arguments about whether lawsuits against the state for false unemployment fraud claims should be allowed to go forward despite a law giving the government immunity.

The court needs no “imprimatur” from the Legislature to uphold the state Constitution and determine damages based on a constitutional violation of claimants’ right to due process, Granzotto said.

“We have a situation where the administrative process cannot address the constitutional claims the plaintiff is making and it can’t award the damages the plaintiff is asking for,” he said. 

“…This court has a role, a special role it seems to me, in the enforcement of constitutional rights.” 



Source link

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Legal Updates/News

Spanish court agrees to extradite Venezuela’s ex-spymaster Carvajal to U.S.

Former Venezuelan intelligence chief Hugo Carvajal stands during his extradition hearing to U.S. at the High Court in Madrid, Spain, September 12, 2019. Emilio Naranjo/Pool via REUTERS MADRID, Oct 20 (Reuters) – Spain’s High Court on Wednesday agreed to extradite former Venezuelan spymaster Hugo Carvajal to the United States, where he faces drug trafficking charges, […]

Read More
Legal Updates/News

Kerala High Court, Kerala High Court Judgement: Can’t Acquit Accused Even If Rape Survivor Of “Easy Virtue”: Kerala High Court

Woman being of easy virtue cannot be reason to absolve, Kerala High Court said. (Representational) Kochi: A woman or girl being of easy virtue or habituated to sexual intercourse cannot be reasons to absolve someone of rape, especially a father who is expected to be the “fortress and refuge” of his daughter, the Kerala High […]

Read More
Legal Updates/News

Heavy security presence at Federal High Court

Journalists, others denied entry into court premises By Ikechukwu Nnochiri – Abuja Security agents have barricaded the Federal High Court Abuja, ahead of scheduled re-arraingment of the detained leader of the proscribed Indigenous People of Biafra, IPOB, Nnamdi Kanu. Kanu is expected to take a fresh plea before trial Justice Binta Nyako, on an amended […]

Read More